pISSN: 2723 - 6609 e-ISSN: 2745-5254
Vol. 4, No. 10 October 2023 http://jist.publikasiindonesia.id/
Doi: 10.59141/jist.v4i10.749 1672
EARLY CHILDHOOD SOCIAL SKILLS DEVELOPMENT THROUGH HYFLEX
LEARNING (FLEXIBLE HYBRID)
Hikmah Munawaroh
1*
, Sri Kuswantono
2
, Sofia Hartati
3
, Yudrik Jahja
4
, Yasmin
Faradiba
5
Universitas Negeri Jakarta, Indonesia
*Correspondence
INFO ARTIKEL
ABSTRACT
Keywords: learning models;
hyflex; social skills; early
childhood education.
Social skills need to be familiarized from an early age because children
will carry these habits into adulthood. This study aims to find a learning
model to develop social-emotional skills through hyflex learning. Face-
to-face, hybrid (blended) learning should give early childhood flexibility
to learn. HyFlex learning gives students choices about how they attend
class through face-to-face, synchronous, and asynchronous technology.
An alternative to achieving this goal is to develop a hybrid learning
model that can be used to teach these early childhood social skills. The
HyFlex Learning Model is a new form of learning in early childhood
education. The selection of the model is based on the initial needs
analysis in DKI Jakarta, where most ECCE educators need a learning
model to develop children's social performance that can be applied
during the Face-to-Face Meeting period to learning activities in PAUD
which is limited in nature can be done optimally. The method used is
research and development (Research and Development) which includes
activities (1) researching and collecting information, including reading
literature, observing classes, and preparing reports on development
needs, (2) planning prototype components to be developed, (3)
developing initial prototypes; (4) conduct limited trials, (5) revise, (6)
test results, (7) revise product designs, (8) conduct field trials
operationally, (9) make final revisions to the media, and (10) disseminate
to various parties. The results of the model trial conducted obtained an
assessment percentage of 83% with a decent assessment category, so this
model is suitable for teaching Social Skills.
Introduction
Social skills should be developed from an early age. The foundation for shaping
one's social behavior is laid during the early years, which makes early childhood
education an important time to ensure children learn social skills (Algan et al., 2022).
Skills Social skills need to be habituated from an early age because children will bring
their habits to adulthood. Developing social skills in early childhood is essential so that
they can interact with others successfully and form healthy relationships throughout life
(Agusniatih & Manopa, 2019).
Comb and Slaby, 1977 revealed in their research the complex social skills necessary
for confident, responsive, and mutually beneficial interaction with other people are
certainly among the most important skills a child must learn. A person's social facility has
profound implications for nearly every facet of life in childhood and adulthood. A lack of
social skills may lead directly to problems in interpersonal relationships or may interfere
Early Childhood Social Skills Development Through Hyflex Learning (Flexible Hybrid)
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 4, No. 10, October 2023 1673
indirectly with optimal functioning in school, occupational, and recreational activities.
Yet, as frequently noted, the training of even the most basic social skills has been almost
completely neglected in American schools (Cappelen, List, Samek, & Tungodden, 2020).
Researchers and clinicians have only recently begun to investigate methods of fostering
specific social skills in children (Othlinghaus-Wulhorst & Hoppe, 2020).
Social skills are very necessary for children to be able to interact with others. Even
the complex social skills necessary for confidence, responsiveness, and mutually
beneficial interactions with others are certainly among the most important skills a child
should learn (Bali, 2017). A person's social skills have profound implications on almost
every facet of life both in childhood and in adulthood. Lack of social skills can lead
directly to problems in interpersonal relationships or can interfere indirectly with optimal
functioning at school, work, and even recreational activities and enjoying pleasure.
However, based on observations and records, the training of the most basic social skills
has been almost completely neglected in schools. Especially during the COVID pandemic
(Martoredjo, 2013).
For more than 2 (two) years, the COVID-19 pandemic has hit almost all over the
world, including Indonesia. The impact is the number of schools that are closed,
limitations in social interaction, and also children's learning. When schools are closed,
learning activities are entirely online. These limitations affect children's social skills.
Both parents and teachers discussed how the transition to remote learning had
impacted students in kindergarten, grade 1, and grade 2. Participants expressed deep
concerns over the negative social and emotional impacts of remote learning for students.
Many teachers described how much their students missed their peers and how important
social interactions are in the early primary grades (Timmons, Cooper, Bozek, & Braund,
2021).
Distance learning (online) has a Social and Emotional impact on Students, parents,
and teachers. How the transition from face-to-face learning to distance learning impacts
students in kindergarten, grade 1, and grade 2. Many children expressed deep concern
over the negative social and emotional impact of distance learning on students. Many
teachers describe how much their students miss their peers and how important social
interaction is in kindergarten and early elementary school classes (Ford, King, Priest, &
Kavanagh, 2017).
As children grow, they learn about social roles, values, and behaviors from the
world around them. Parents, siblings, extended family, peers, and teachers all have a role
to play in shaping a child's social skills.
Social skills are vital in enabling an individual to have and maintain positive
interactions with others. Many of these skills are crucial in making and sustaining
friendships. Social interactions do not always run smoothly and an individual needs to be
able to implement appropriate strategies, such as conflict resolution when difficulties in
interactions arise. It is also important for individuals to have ’empathy’ (i.e.being able to
put yourself into someone else’s shoes and recognize their feelings) as it allows them to
respond in an understanding and caring way to how others are feeling.
Hikmah Munawaroh, Sri Kuswantono, Sofia Hartati, Yudrik Jahja, Yasmin Faradiba
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 4, No. 10, October 2023 1674
Social skills are essential in enabling individuals to have and maintain positive
interactions with others. Many of these skills are essential in forging and maintaining
friendships. Social interaction does not always go smoothly and an individual needs to be
able to implement appropriate strategies, such as conflict resolution when difficulties in
interaction arise. It is also important for individuals to have 'empathy' (i.e. being able to
put themselves in someone else's shoes and recognize their feelings) as it allows them to
respond in a way that understands and cares about the feelings of others. For this reason,
a learning model is needed for early childhood to support the development of social skills.
Because the learning model is applied to early childhood learning. Especially now in
PAUD learning is carried out through limited face-to-face, so there is a tendency when
face-to-face focuses on academic development only. For this reason, a learning model is
needed that can support the development of children's social skills (Munawaroh, Hartati,
Kuswantono, Faradiba, & Yahya, 2022).
The first study to examine the causal impact of early childhood education on the
social preferences of children. We compare children who, at 34 years old, were
randomized into either a full-time preschool, a parenting program, or a control group. We
returned to the children when they reached 68 years of age and conducted a series of
incentivized experiments to elicit their social preferences. We find that early childhood
education has a strong causal impact on social preferences. Our findings highlight the
importance of taking a broad perspective when designing and evaluating early childhood
educational programs (Cappelen et al., 2020).
There is a causal impact on early childhood education with children's social
preferences. The above research shows that early childhood education has a strong causal
impact on social preferences. These findings highlight the importance of taking a broad
perspective when designing and evaluating early childhood education programs. The a
need to develop a learning model in early childhood that flexibly supports face-to-face
and online learning according to the child's choice. So even though a child chooses online
learning, various skills and knowledge still develop optimally (Hikmah, 2022). Based on
the results of a survey conducted by Oternborn the Survey results revealed a high degree
of engagement with digital tablets in preschools, with activities directed toward various
subject-related, social, and generic skills. Programming, invention, construction and
creation, problem-solving, and design emerged saliently as tablet activities in technology
subject areas. Opportunities for providing meaningful learning tasks and digital
adaptability were seen as pedagogical benefits of using tablets, but increasing
expectations to integrate tablet activities with an accompanying lack of digital skills were
expressed as limitations. Teachers’ recommendations for future tablet use included
defining clearer curriculum guidelines for tablet implementation and adequate training
for acquiring digital competence (Otterborn, Schönborn, & Hultén, 2019).
The survey results revealed a high level of engagement with digital tablets in pre-
school education, with activities geared towards a range of subject-related, social, and
general skills. Programming, invention, construction and creation, problem-solving, and
design emerged prominently as tablet activities in the subject area of technology.
Early Childhood Social Skills Development Through Hyflex Learning (Flexible Hybrid)
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 4, No. 10, October 2023 1675
Opportunities to deliver meaningful learning assignments and digital adaptability are seen
as pedagogical benefits of tablet use, but expectations of integrating tablet activities with
teachers' limited digital skills are difficult to implement. On that basis, if children's social
skills want to develop optimally, learning programs both offline and online must be
accompanied by digital skills teachers. In addition, it requires patience from educators
and parents who interact with children.
Children, who are studying in playgroups, kindergartens, and elementary schools
today, are Generation Alpha, who are close to Information Technology (IT). They can
access and absorb various information. In addition to school, parents also play a role in
the social-emotional development of children. Therefore, a learning model that can
optimize the social-emotional abilities of children is needed. The social problems of
children today are quite concerning (Sihadi & Kuswantono, 2020).
Children studying in playgroups, kindergartens, and elementary schools today are
Generation Alpha, which is close to Information Technology (IT). They can access and
absorb various information through digital technology. Early childhood who study at this
ECCE institution is the Alpha Generation where he is amid advanced information
technology in its golden age. They have known the world of technology and the internet
from an early age and are also known as digital natives. This makes online learning
already familiar to them. However, on the other hand, the learning presented today by
ECCE educators is not interesting according to their interests. This happens because of
the limited ability of educators to design learning and provide digital media that interests
children. So that the learning held is not by the expected goals. A solution is needed to
motivate children's learning and develop children's social skills in the midst of limited
online and face-to-face learning.
HyFlex learning is a potential answer to this problem. However, there has not been
much research into this mode of instruction. Studies on HyFlex have looked at HyFlex
from the perspective of student attendance, engagement, and performance. Miller, Riser,
and Griffiths (2013) found that students in HyFlex courses enjoyed the flexibility and that
the technology-enhanced student participation. They found that the students in the course
overall found HyFlex to be an effective mode of instruction, but that more research was
needed. However, the scope of this research is limited in comparison to online and
blended learning (Howell, 2022).
HyFlex learning is a potential answer to apply to limited face-to-face learning.
However, there hasn't been much research on this way of teaching, especially in early
childhood. Studies on HyFlex have looked at HyFlex from the perspective of student
attendance, engagement, and performance. Miller, Riser, and Griffiths (2013) found that
students in HyFlex learning enjoy flexibility and that technology increases student
participation. They found that students in the course as a whole found HyFlex to be an
effective mode of instruction, so it needs more research, especially for current wholeness.
Research Methods
Hikmah Munawaroh, Sri Kuswantono, Sofia Hartati, Yudrik Jahja, Yasmin Faradiba
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 4, No. 10, October 2023 1676
This research was conducted with an educational research and development
approach (Bord and Gall, 2003).
Research Context
This research was conducted in Jakarta. This area was chosen because this area is
quite strategic and reachable. The existing ECCE teachers are quite enthusiastic and have
a high commitment to optimizing children's growth and development, especially in
optimizing children's social and emotional. Parents in this region can also be invited to
cooperate in optimizing children's growth and development so that a prototype of
developing a model involving people can be done. In addition, based on a survey
conducted by the author on social-emotional competence which includes social skills,
problematic behavior, academic competence, recognizing and managing emotions,
emotional regulation, and emotional expression in children aged 4-6 years in DKI Jakarta
during 2018, it was found that the average child in DKI has sufficient results and there
are still some who are still lacking, So an intervention model (learning activities) is
needed that helps children train their social emotions. These activities should be
integrated with learning at school and involve parents at home.
Sample
Samples were taken from children aged 4-6 years. Research subjects will fill in their
data, children's data, be involved in program development and educators are given
training for the application of learning models with parental involvement. Parents
involved with ECCE institution programs are given direction from ECCE institutions and
monitoring program implementation is carried out through filling out program
implementation assessment sheets. The sample in this study was early childhood
Procedure
This research is a development research. To see the feasibility of the model, an
evaluation of the model was carried out through trials. The steps of evaluation research
include (1) Clarification of the reasons for conducting the evaluation; (2) Choose an
evaluation model; (3) Identify the parties concerned; (4) Determination of the
components to be evaluated; (5) Prepare evaluation schedules and activity schedules; (6)
Data collection and analysis; (7) Reporting of evaluation results (David Strahan at al. in
Sukmadinata, 2009; p.132).
Empirical Model
The empirical model used in this study was to evaluate the social-emotional
learning model with parental involvement. The qualitative data obtained is then
reprocessed to see the percentage value of the effectiveness of the social-emotional
learning model using the following formula:
P = (∑χ)/n X 100%
Information:
P = Effectiveness of social-emotional learning model
∑χ = Number of scores obtained by research subjects
n = Maximum score (Anas Sudjono, 2003, p.318)
Description of Statistics
Early Childhood Social Skills Development Through Hyflex Learning (Flexible Hybrid)
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 4, No. 10, October 2023 1677
The description of the research data can be seen in Diagrams 1 and 2 of the figure
describing statistical data on the application of social and emotional learning models with
parental involvement in East Jakarta.
Results and Discussion
Based on the trial activities carried out in the field, the results of testing the teacher
and parent program are interested in the program made by the author. But to be applied
in schools still waiting for normal learning conditions. Based on the results of trials
conducted with digital media that have been developed by the author, based on trials of
activities carried out in the field, the results of testing the teacher and parent programs are
interested in the program made by the author. Based on the results of trials conducted
with the hyperflex learning model that the author has developed, the results can be
described as follows:
Table 1
Model Development Test Results
Attractiveness 85, quality 80, material 85, Ease of use 78, Usability 87 average
figures of 83%.
Conclusion
Social skills are behaviors that encourage positive interactions with others.
Teaching children social skills is one of the most complex aspects of parenting, but the
benefits will be felt as children become adults. Early childhood is naturally egocentric.
Even when playing or interacting with others, many children have difficulty sharing,
empathizing, collaborating, and cooperating. Children develop skills to play alongside
others, to play collaboratively, and to form special friendships during their early
childhood years. Teaching children social skills is an important part of the early childhood
learning journey.
The development of social skills in early childhood is the task of adults, especially
parents and early childhood educators. So that children can grow and develop properly.
70
75
80
85
90
Hasil Uji Coba
Model Pembelajaran Hyflex Keterampilan
Sosial
Column1 Series 2 Column2
Hikmah Munawaroh, Sri Kuswantono, Sofia Hartati, Yudrik Jahja, Yasmin Faradiba
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 4, No. 10, October 2023 1678
The learning model developed by the author is a hyflex learning model to develop social
skills. Through the application of this model, schools and parents work together to
optimize children's social skills. The implementation of this learning model in schools
through play activities that are specifically designed and designed to develop children's
social skills. Development tools are used through Hyflex learning by utilizing face-to-
face play activities at school and existing digital facilities such as digital whiteboards and
pallets for those who learn online. Based on the results of the experiments that the author
conducted, it can be concluded that this model is feasible to be used to teach social skills.
Early Childhood Social Skills Development Through Hyflex Learning (Flexible Hybrid)
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 4, No. 10, October 2023 1679
Bibliography
Agusniatih, Andi, & Manopa, Jane M. (2019). Keterampilan sosial anak usia dini: teori
dan metode pengembangan. Edu Publisher.
Algan, Yann, Beasley, Elizabeth, Côté, Sylvana, Park, Jungwee, Tremblay, Richard E.,
& Vitaro, Frank. (2022). The impact of childhood social skills and self-control
training on economic and noneconomic outcomes: Evidence from a randomized
experiment using administrative data. American Economic Review, 112(8), 2553
2579. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20200224
Bali, Muhammad Mushfi El Iq. (2017). Model interaksi sosial dalam mengelaborasi
keterampilan sosial. Pedagogik: Jurnal Pendidikan, 4(2).
https://doi.org/10.33650/pjp.v4i2.19
Cappelen, Alexander, List, John, Samek, Anya, & Tungodden, Bertil. (2020). The effect
of early-childhood education on social preferences. Journal of Political Economy,
128(7), 27392758.
Ford, Rebecca, King, Tania, Priest, Naomi, & Kavanagh, Anne. (2017). Bullying and
mental health and suicidal behaviour among 14-to 15-year-olds in a representative
sample of Australian children. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry,
51(9), 897908. https://doi.org/10.1177/0004867417700275
Hikmah, M. Pd. (2022). Teknologi Informasi Komunikasi Pada Pendidikan Anak Usia
Dini. Nas Media Pustaka.
Howell, Emily. (2022). HyFlex model of higher education: understanding the promise of
flexibility. On the Horizon: The International Journal of Learning Futures, 30(4),
173181. https://doi.org/10.1108/OTH-04-2022-0019
Martoredjo, Nikodemus Thomas. (2013). Meningkatkan prestasi belajar di perguruan
tinggi dengan mengembangkan kecerdasan emosional. Humaniora, 4(2), 1093
1104.
Munawaroh, Hikmah, Hartati, Sofia, Kuswantono, Sri, Faradiba, Yasmin, & Yahya,
Yudrik. (2022). Mengembangkan Kapasitas Pendidik Paud Dalam Menerapkan
Model Pembelajaran Hyflex Pada Tatap Muka Terbatas Di Paud. Prosiding
Seminar Nasional Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat, 3, SNPPM2022P-420.
Othlinghaus-Wulhorst, Julia, & Hoppe, H. Ulrich. (2020). A technical and conceptual
framework for serious role-playing games in the area of social skill training.
Frontiers in Computer Science, 2, 28.
Otterborn, Anna, Schönborn, Konrad, & Hultén, Magnus. (2019). Surveying preschool
teachers’ use of digital tablets: general and technology education related findings.
International Journal of Technology and Design Education, 29(4), 717737.
Sihadi, D. W., & Kuswantono, Sri. (2020). Pengembangan Kapasistas Pendidik Dalam
Hikmah Munawaroh, Sri Kuswantono, Sofia Hartati, Yudrik Jahja, Yasmin Faradiba
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 4, No. 10, October 2023 1680
Menerapkan Pembelajaran Sosial Emosi Di Kelas Virtual Pada Masa Pandemik
Covid 19. Prosiding Seminar Nasional Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat, 1,
SNPPM2020P-1.
Timmons, Kristy, Cooper, Amanda, Bozek, Emma, & Braund, Heather. (2021). The
impacts of COVID-19 on early childhood education: Capturing the unique
challenges associated with remote teaching and learning in K-2. Early Childhood
Education Journal, 49(5), 887901.