pISSN: 2723 - 6609 e-ISSN: 2745-5254
Vol. 5, No. 9 September 2024 http://jist.publikasiindonesia.id/
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 9, September 2024 3318
Application of Problem-Based Learning (PBL) Learning
Model to Improve Student Learning Outcomes in Arithmetic
Row Material Class XI SMAN 6 Southwest Aceh
Khahona Afrinia
1*
, Baidullah
2
STKIP Muhammadiyah Aceh Barat Daya, Indonesia
Email:
1*
2
*Correspondence
ABSTRACT
Keywords: learning;
problem-based learning;
arithmetic line.
In this era of globalization, the low mathematics learning
outcomes of students at the high school level, especially at
SMAN 6 Aceh Barat South, are caused by the fact that in the
learning process, teachers only focus on using less
competent methods, so students get bored easily. The
purpose of this study is to determine the completeness of
student learning outcomes through Problem-Based Learning
on Arithmetic Rows and Series Materials. This research is
classified as a classroom action research that is carried out in
two research cycles. In each research cycle, there are 4 stages
consisting of planning, implementation, observation, and
reflection stages. Data collection in the study was carried out
using the test method. The data obtained in the study were
then analyzed by analytical descriptive analysis techniques
and qualitative descriptive analysis. The results of the study
showed that the average student learning outcome in the
pretest was 65.4 and increased in the post-test, which was
70.9. Based on these results, it can be seen that there is an
increase in student learning outcomes in each cycle.
Therefore, it can be concluded that the application of the
problem-based learning model can significantly improve the
mathematics learning outcomes of high school students.
Introduction
In the implementation of education, there is a learning process, where students at
each level are required to take part in certain subjects. One of the subjects taught at almost
every level of education is mathematics. Mathematics is generally defined as the field of
science about logic regarding shapes, arrangements, and concepts related to others
(Rahman & Hapizah, 2021). The educational process is essentially an empowerment
process, which is a process to reveal the potential that exists in humans as individuals
who can then contribute to their nation. Education is increasingly important in the process
of technological transformation, especially in today's era of globalization, especially
Application of Problem-Based Learning (PBL) Learning Model to Improve Student Learning
Outcomes in Arithmetic Row Material Class XI SMAN 6 Southwest Aceh
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 9, September 2024 3319
related to increasing knowledge in educational institutions through learning models
(Khakim, Santi, US, Putri, & Fauzi, 2022).
To achieve learning targets, teachers are required to be able to develop and use the
right learning model. In connection with this, efforts are made to provide opportunities
for students to improve Mathematics learning outcomes by using a Problem-Based
Learning model that is not only teacher-centered but also student-centered. One of the
ways to strengthen understanding of Mathematics learning outcomes is learning that can
provide opportunities for students to understand problems, provide answers or opinions,
and then draw conclusions (Novelni & Sukma, 2021).
According to Sukma, (2021) one of the right learning models is the Problems Based
Learning (PBL. Problem-Based Learning is a learning model that uses real problems that
are unstructured and open, in addition, the Problem-Based Learning model that uses real
problems with an open context and innovative learning can invite students to learn
actively in solving problems.
The ability to understand concepts plays a big role in determining student learning
outcomes in mathematics learning. Meanwhile, according to (Tyas, 2017), Problem-
Based Learning (PBL) is one of the learning models that makes problems the basis for
students to learn, problem-based learning is included in the category of teaching via
problem-solving, where learning mathematical content is carried out through the
presentation of inquiry-oriented problems. The problems presented in PBL are problems
in daily life and these problems can stimulate students to learn this problem based on the
knowledge and experience that students have had, so that from the experience that
students have had, new knowledge and experience will be formed. Therefore, having this
ability by students will make it easier to learn and solve mathematical problems. In
mathematics learning activities, emphasis should be placed on activities that can increase
understanding of concepts so that students have good basic skills to achieve other
mathematical skills such as reasoning, communication, connection, and problem-solving.
The learning process in the classroom by directing children to the ability to use formulas,
memorize formulas, mathematics only to do problems, rarely taught to analyze, and use
mathematics in daily life does not encourage children to develop their thinking skills
(ASTUTI, 2022).
Based on the observations and experiences that the researcher has observed, the
causes of students' lack of understanding of the material include students' interest in
participating in learning is still low, students thinking the subject is difficult, students'
initial knowledge is still low, students' low understanding of concepts, students lack
learning the material that has been given, teachers have not maximized the application of
innovative learning models. The Importance of Sharing Innovative Learning Practices
Understanding the material, this learning practice is expected to motivate other teachers
to design and implement innovative learning The role of a teacher who have the task of
educating, teaching, guiding, directing, training, assessing, and evaluating students.
According to (Nurlaelah, 2023), a teacher's responsibility is to carry out all stages or
phases of innovative teaching (creative and innovative learning, which is integrated with
Khahona Afrinia, Baidullah
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 9, September 2024 3320
and by using learning methods, group discussions, and presentations so that learning goals
can be achieved).
The Problem-based learning (PBL) learning model is one of the innovative learning
models that can provide active learning conditions to students. Problem-Based Learning
(PBL) is a learning model that uses real problems as a context for students to develop
students problem-solving and critical-thinking skills. The problems used must be based
on daily life that is close to the student's life so that students can find mathematical
concepts on their own, especially arithmetic. The presentation of these problems can bring
students closer to mathematics and students can know the benefits of mathematics in daily
life and provide meaningful experiences in learning so that there can be an increase in
student learning (Aklimawati, Mahmuzah, & Rahmat, 2019). The role of teachers
includes a classroom manager who organizes and monitors student learning activities,
becomes a facilitator and motivator in implementing Problem-Based Learning, ensures
that Problem-Based Learning runs well, as a mediator between learning materials and
students, namely the teacher's ability to create learning media that can bridge students
with learning materials, and as an observer of student activity in the process Learning.
The teacher's responsibility here is as an administrator who prepares learning tools
according to the material and characteristics of students.
The error in determining the stage of problem-solving and the lack of understanding
of the meaning of the problem are the causes of failure to solve the problem. These
difficulties cause students to lack confidence when solving problems and have an impact
on low student learning outcomes. The difficulties experienced by students are caused by
a lack of attention and involvement of students in learning. For this reason, in the process
of learning mathematics, students generally do not like the field of mathematics study.
This is due to the tendency that what is displayed or taught to students is a series of
abstract and boring formulas (Widyasari, Miyono, & Saputro, 2024).
Therefore, it is necessary to choose a learning model that increases attention and
learning, so that students understand the meaning of formulas and concepts in arithmetic
rows and series materials. Several studies show that the learning model can be used to
improve learning achievement with the PBL model can be modified to further optimize
the quality of learning. Powerpoint media can be used to make the PBL model more
attractive. Problem-based learning (PBL) is a learning model with a student learning
approach to authentic problems so that he can compile his knowledge, grow and develop
higher skills and inquiry, make students independent, and increase confidence. In this
case, a similar study was also conducted by (Mulbar, Bernard, & Pesona, 2018) who
concluded that "through the application of the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) learning
model on Arithmetic problem material, the completeness of learning outcomes can be
achieved. Social arithmetic material is a material that has been taught since junior high
school grade VII in the even semester. According to (Aslam, Suparji, & Rijanto, 2021)
Social arithmetic material is one of the mathematics subject matter that must be
understood by grade VII students, social arithmetic material includes sales and purchase
prices, profits, losses, and break-even, profit and loss percentages, discounts, taxes, gross,
Application of Problem-Based Learning (PBL) Learning Model to Improve Student Learning
Outcomes in Arithmetic Row Material Class XI SMAN 6 Southwest Aceh
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 9, September 2024 3321
net value, and single interest. The social arithmetic material in this study is unit price,
selling price, purchase price, profit and loss, profit and discount percentage.
Based on some of the explanations and theories above, the researcher is interested
in conducting a study entitled "Application of Problem-Based Learning (PBL) Learning
Model to Improve Student Learning Outcomes in Arithmetic Materials for Class XI
SMAN 6 Aceh Barat South.
Method
The method used in writing is a literature review. The literature studied is research
books and articles. The books studied are related to Educational Psychology, and
Teaching and Learning. The research articles studied are articles related to the Problem-
based Learning model. The focus of the study is on the theoretical foundation of Problem-
Based Learning, the character of the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) model, and the
implementation of the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) model (Ardianti, Sujarwanto, &
Surahman, 2021). The research approach used in this study is quantitative. The
quantitative approach is numerical data processed using statistical methods.1 While the
research method used in this study is the quasi-experimental method. The researcher used
this method because the samples taken were ordinary classes without changing the
existing structure. The design used in this study is the Pretest-Posttest Equivalent Group
Design. This research was conducted in two classes, namely the control class and the
experimental class. In the experimental class, a pre-test is given to see the ability of
student learning outcomes, after which learning treatment is given using the Problem-
Based Learning (PBL) learning model. After the learning is complete, students are then
given a final test (post-test) to see changes in student learning outcomes. Similarly, in the
control class, before the material is taught using direct learning, a pre-test will also be
given. After the learning is completed immediately, the final test is given.
Results and Discussion
In this study, student learning outcomes are seen from the results of the pre-test and
post-test given. The test is in the form of an essay consisting of 3 questions. The learning
outcomes are expected to be able to determine profits and losses and their percentages
and be able to solve real problems related to profit and loss.
The results of the pre-test showed the initial condition of student learning outcomes
which as a whole in the experimental and control classes were still resolved. However,
after the two were given treatment, namely in an experimental class using the Problem-
Based Learning (PBL) learning model. While the control class was treated using a direct
learning model, only then did the difference in student learning outcomes in social
arithmetic material be seen. This can be seen in the learning outcome scores in both
classes. In the experimental class, it appears that the learning outcomes of students
increase by using the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) learning model, this can be seen
from the results of the post-test of the experimental class, where the average score of the
post-test is higher than the average of the pre-test, where the average score of the pre-test
Khahona Afrinia, Baidullah
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 9, September 2024 3322
is 65.4 and the posttest is 70.9 by using the t-test at the level of significance = 0.05 and
the degree of freedom (dk) = 24, the t-table of 1.71 and the t-count of 13.38 which means
that the t-count is more from the t-table, it can be concluded that student learning
outcomes increase with the Problem Based Learning (PBL) learning model.
During the learning process with the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) model,
students are faced with a real problem. Students understand the problem by observing and
reading the problem presented. Students look enthusiastic when observing and
understanding the problem. Students also actively ask questions about things they do not
understand, both to the teacher and their classmates. Students are also active in discussing
and collecting information from books, as well as asking directly to teachers to solve
problems in the LKPD that has been given.
At the stage of developing and presenting the work, students send two people from
their group to present answers to the completed LKPD. Students confidently explain the
results of their work to other visiting groups. This stage trains them to communicate the
ideas they have gotten. In addition, students can creatively develop character in
themselves. Based on the description above, it can be seen that the Problem-Based
Learning (PBL) learning model can improve student learning outcomes. This is in line
with research conducted by Yenni Fitria which concluded that "Through the application
of the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) learning model, it can improve students'
mathematics learning outcomes on problem-solving materials involving money (Yenni,
2019)".
Based on the results of data processing using N-Gain in the experimental class
(table 4.4), it was found that 6 students had high n-gain values, 14 students had medium
n-gain values and 4 students had low n-gain values. The results show that the n-gain value
of the experimental class is in a moderate position. Meanwhile, in the control class (table
4.12), it was found that 2 students had a high n-gain level, 7 students at a medium n-gain
level, and the remaining 16 students at a low n-gain level. The results show that the n-
gain value in the control class is in a low position. In addition, the average post-test score
of the learning outcomes of the experimental class students was (((x), = 70.9) and the
average post-test score of the control class was ((x), = 57.56) It was seen that the average
score of the experiment was higher than the average score of the control.
The data that has been analyzed obtained obtained the t-value for both classes, namely t-
calculation = 3.1697 and t-table 1.68. This result results in t-calculation ≥ t-table, which
is 3.1697 >1.68, thus it can be concluded that "the learning outcomes of students who are
taught with the Problem-Based Learning (PBL) learning model are higher than the
learning outcomes of students who are taught with direct learning".
Table 1
Acquisition of pre-test and post-test data of the Experiment class
No
Name
Group
Skor
pre-
test
Post-test
scores
Effectiveness
Application of Problem-Based Learning (PBL) Learning Model to Improve Student Learning
Outcomes in Arithmetic Row Material Class XI SMAN 6 Southwest Aceh
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 9, September 2024 3323
1
2
3
4
6
1
AH
Experiment
64
95
Tall
2
AP
Experiment
45
55
Low
3
AR
Experiment
60
82
Keep
4
AA
Experiment
60
85
Keep
5
THREE
Experiment
25
60
Keep
6
FAA
Experiment
15
70
Keep
7
GT
Experiment
20
82
Tall
8
JR
Experiment
25
85
Tall
9
KR
Experiment
20
84
Tall
10
MN
Experiment
15
73
Keep
11
LS
Experiment
50
92
Tall
12
SR
Experiment
45
95
Tall
13
NS
Experiment
21
64
Keep
14
MP
Experiment
5
70
Keep
15
THE
Experiment
35
79
Keep
16
IN
Experiment
45
80
Keep
17
RK
Experiment
15
40
Low
18
KS
Experiment
35
75
Keep
19
CR
Experiment
20
70
Keep
20
NO
Experiment
25
43
Low
21
YEAR
Experiment
10
70
Keep
22
THREE
Experiment
40
76
Keep
23
CS
Experiment
35
74
Keep
24
NOT
Experiment
15
71
Keep
25
For
example
Experiment
10
36
Low
Table 2
Acquisition of pre-test and post-test data of the Control class
No
Name
Group
Skor
pre-test
Post-
test
scores
N-
Gain
Effectiveness
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
AH
Experiment
30
45
0,21
Low
2
AP
Experiment
65
69
0,11
Low
3
AR
Experiment
45
70
0,45
Keep
4
AA
Experiment
60
64
0,10
Low
5
THREE
Experiment
15
70
0,65
Keep
6
FAA
Experiment
25
40
0.20
Low
7
GT
Experiment
45
50
0,09
Low
8
JR
Experiment
40
52
0,20
Low
9
KR
Experiment
10
72
0.69
Keep
10
MN
Experiment
45
60
0,27
Low
Khahona Afrinia, Baidullah
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 9, September 2024 3324
11
LS
Experiment
24
35
0,14
Low
12
SR
Experiment
45
75
0,55
Keep
13
NS
Experiment
25
70
0,60
Keep
14
MP
Experiment
35
52
0,26
Low
15
THE
Experiment
20
80
0,75
Tall
16
IN
Experiment
45
60
0,27
Low
17
RK
Experiment
34
50
0,24
Low
18
KS
Experiment
35
75
0,62
Keep
19
CR
Experiment
30
80
0,71
Tall
20
NO
Experiment
15
35
0,24
Low
21
YEAR
Experiment
15
32
0,20
Low
22
THREE
Experiment
30
45
0,51
Keep
23
CS
Experiment
60
80
0,50
Keep
24
NOT
Experiment
20
35
0,19
Low
25
For
example
Experiment
40
55
0,25
Low
The stages of Problem Based Learning (PBL) learning that the author believes can
improve learning outcomes, namely the first stage and the third stage. The first stage is
the stage of student orientation to the problem. At this stage, students are faced with real
problems, students feel challenged and motivated to solve the problems presented.
According to Ngalimun, if learning begins with a problem, especially a contextual
problem, then there can be a cognitive imbalance in the student. This situation encourages
curiosity so it raises various questions related to the problem. If the question has arisen,
then their intrinsic motivation to learn will appear. The third stage is to guide the
investigation independently or in groups. At this stage, students discuss defining
problems, and then conduct experiments to get explanations and problem-solving in
LKPD. So they construct their knowledge. This is in line with the view of constructivism
expressed by Cobb (Suherman, 2013) who said that learning is seen as an active and
constructive process where students try to solve problems that arise as they actively
participate in mathematics exercises in class.
Based on the results of the above research, it can be concluded that problem-based
learning is an effective learning model that benefits to supports students' achievement in
learning Mathematics, especially Arithmetic row material.
Conclusion
Based on the research that the author has carried out at SMAN 6 Aceh Barat South,
the t-count > t-table was obtained which is 13.3885 > 1.71. At a significant level = 0.05.
so it can be concluded that the learning outcomes of students who are taught with the
Problem-Based Learning (PBL) learning model are higher than the learning outcomes of
students who are taught with direct learning.
Application of Problem-Based Learning (PBL) Learning Model to Improve Student Learning
Outcomes in Arithmetic Row Material Class XI SMAN 6 Southwest Aceh
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 9, September 2024 3325
Bibliography
Aklimawati, Aklimawati, Mahmuzah, Rifaatul, & Rahmat, Qidmi Rahmat Qidmi. (2019).
Pembelajaran Problem Based Learning pada Materi Barisan dan Deret di SMA
Negeri 1 Darul Imarah. Jurnal Serambi Akademica, 7(2), 147152.
Ardianti, Resti, Sujarwanto, Eko, & Surahman, Endang. (2021). Problem-based Learning:
Apa dan Bagaimana. DIFFRACTION: Journal for Physics Education and Applied
Physics, 3(1), 2735.
Aslam, Lera Kurniatul, Suparji, Suparji, & Rijanto, Tri. (2021). The effect of problem
based learning model on learning outcomes in the vocational high school students.
International Journal for Educational and Vocational Studies, 3(4), 264267.
Astuti, E. N. I. Setiyaningsih D. W. I. (2022). Penerapan Problem Based Learning Dalam
Meningkatkan Hasil Belajar Siswa. Educational: Jurnal Inovasi Pendidikan &
Pengajaran, 2(4), 317324.
Khakim, Nor, Santi, Noor Mela, US, Acep Bahrul, Putri, Erlina, & Fauzi, Ahmad. (2022).
Penerapan Model Pembelajaran Problem Based Learning Dalam Meningkatkan
Motivasi Belajar PPKn Di SMP YAKPI 1 DKI Jaya. Jurnal Citizenship Virtues,
2(2), 347358.
Mulbar, Usman, Bernard, B., & Pesona, Rian Rasmi. (2018). Penerapan model
pembelajaran berbasis masalah dengan strategi pembelajaran diferensiasi pada
peserta didik kelas VIII. Issues in Mathematics Education (IMED), 1(1), 16.
Novelni, Delsi, & Sukma, Elfia. (2021). Analisis langkah-langkah model problem based
learning dalam pembelajaran tematik terpadu di sekolah dasar menurut pandangan
para ahli. Journal of Basic Education Studies, 4(1), 38693888.
Nurlaelah, Nurlaelah. (2023). Problem-Based Learning Method for Improving the
Learning Achievement of Students. Edunesia: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan, 4(2),
447457.
Rahman, M. Taufiq Qur, & Hapizah, Muhamad Yusup. (2021). Penerapan Problem
Based Learning Menggunakan Bahan Ajar Berbasis Android pada Materi Barisan
dan Deret Aritmetika. Lentera Sriwijaya: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Matematika,
3(2), 116.
Tyas, Retnaning. (2017). Kesulitan penerapan problem based learning dalam
pembelajaran matematika. Jurnal Tecnoscienza, 2(1), 4352.
Widyasari, Devi, Miyono, Noor, & Saputro, Susilo Adi. (2024). Peningkatan hasil belajar
melalui model pembelajaran problem based learning. Jurnal Inovasi, Evaluasi Dan
Pengembangan Pembelajaran (JIEPP), 4(1), 6167.