pISSN: 2723 - 6609 e-ISSN: 2745-5254
Vol. 5, No. 7 July 2024 http://jist.publikasiindonesia.id/
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3089
Integral Emotions and Incidental Emotions of Consumers in
Impulse Buying Behavior Online
Erna Ferrinadewi
Universitas Widya Kartika, Indonesia
Email:
*Correspondence
ABSTRACT
Keywords: Emotions,
Integral Emotions,
Incidental Emotion,
Pembelian Impulsif,
Keputusan Pembelian.
Impulsive buying has been vigorously studied from different
perspectives. In the science of Consumer Behavior,
impulsive buying depicts a consumer’s buying decision
which is spontaneous and quick, quite often without the
presence of any cognitive activity. Prior studies often
observed how this impulsive buying is influenced by
consumers’ emotions, but only a few studies observe how
Integral Emotions and Incidental Emotions influence the
collective decision of impulsive buying and its emotional
impact. Involving 100 respondents with prior experiences of
impulsive buying, the data would then be analyzed using the
Partial Leas Square-SEM after considering the ability of this
statistical model to analyze data below 500 respondents.
Results showed that there is a significant negative
relationship between Incidental Emotion the impulsive
buying, but a negative influence towards Integral Emotion
on the impulsive buying decision. Besides that, there is a
significant positive influence of impulsive buying towards
the emotion afterward.
Introduction
Today's consumer purchases are not always driven by rational motives, many
purchases that consumers make are based on the emotional state that occurs while the
purchase decision process is ongoing. Purchases made by consumers can be driven by the
functional needs provided by the benefits of the product and emotional needs related to
the psychological aspect of product purchases. These formed emotions can occur as a
result of the contribution of various exposures to stimuli such as sound. The aroma, color,
and taste of the product symbol
The panic buying phenomenon, which occurred during the pandemic when the fear
of a highly contagious disease outbreak caused large-scale social restrictions to cause
people to buy in large quantities, is proof that emotional conditions have a stronger impact
on purchasing decisions (Patiro, Budiyanti, & Hendarto, 2022). Consumers may even use
purchases as a way to control the negative feelings they feel at certain times. In the context
of the panic buying phenomenon, buying behavior is the result of consumers' efforts to
Erna Ferrinadewi
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3090
control their emotions of fear of the disease outbreak at that time (Sharma, Dwivedi,
Mariani, & Islam, 2022).
Post-purchase consumer behavior is also largely determined by the emotional state
of consumers, in this case, what they feel in their satisfaction. In purchase intent,
complaints and the desire to buy or replace another brand are also influenced by the
emotions felt after the purchase. The emotions felt by consumers in the context of service
products are determined by the condition of the physical environment and the state of the
social environment (Naami & Hezarkhani, 2018). In the case of impulsive purchases, it
is often associated with being a factor in both external and internal situations (Haq &
Abbasi, 2016).
In marketing, consumer emotions are an important factor because many efforts in
building brands are aimed at creating a close emotional relationship between consumers
and brands. This strong emotional connection with the brand will lead the purchase
decision process to be more profitable for marketers and prevent a deep sense of
disappointment when the product fails to deliver on what it promises.
Emotional Marketing is widely used by marketers to get a response from potential
buyers by utilizing emotions in all marketing and advertising efforts so that the product
is known, remembered, purchased and even recommended to others. Generally, the
emotions used are emotions such as happiness, sadness, sadness, or fear to provoke a
response from potential buyers (Sharma et al., 2022). Even some experts consider that
emotions are also able to sharpen buyers' rational considerations. In its development, the
brand's next effort is to build an emotional connection with potential buyers to drive the
purchase decision process. Emotions are mental states that arise as a result of the human
cognitive process. This cognition process is also followed by a psychological process,
even the presence of these emotions can also affect the results of the cognition process
that runs in the purchase decision (Achar, So, Agrawal, & Duhachek, 2016).
On the other hand, impulse buying is a tendency to make purchases that are made
spontaneously by consumers and even seem sudden without prior deep thought and
decided immediately in front of the product to be purchased. In impulse purchases,
consumers do not evaluate information on various product alternatives and do not
consider the consequences after their purchase (Kabamba & Smith, 2022), it can be
concluded that impulse purchases do not involve a cognition process that tends to be
rational.
Impulsive purchases have been found in previous studies departing from sensory
experiences experienced by consumers such as store atmosphere, room layout, store
aroma, and creating integral emotions, so some experts argue that impulsive purchases
will occur a lot in the store environment and rarely occur in online purchase situations.
This is because, in the situation of online purchases, the sensors that can be applied to
online purchases are limited to the eyes and ears so that consumers are less likely to make
purchases spontaneously (Moreira, Fortes, & Santiago, 2017).
On the other hand, for online purchases, a close emotional relationship is also
needed between buyers in order to reduce the risk of purchase, brands are used by
Integral Emotions and Incidental Emotions of Consumers in Impulse Buying Behavior
Online
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3091
consumers as a substitute for information related to the quality of products and services.
Consumers have a close emotional connection to overcome the fear of the amount of risk
that needs to be borne later if the purchase does not meet expectations.
Several previous studies have found that feelings of anxiety and depression (Yu,
2022), feelings of boredom (Sunstorm, 2013) felt by consumers before a purchase are
incidental emotions that encourage online buying behavior, but impulsive buying
behavior and how emotions after impulsive purchases have not been researched enough.
The online purchase decision environment has been influenced more by price factors,
product availability, other buyers' ratings, social media activities (Chan, Cheung, & Lee,
2017), the problem of trust in online stores (Kamis & Zulkiffli, 2020), the characteristics
of online stores and browsing activities, electronic word of mouth.
Impulse Buying
Many concepts and literature related to impulse buying are focused on the factor of
intention and planning before purchase, which is followed by the time factor needed in
the decision-making process and the accompaniment of emotions felt by consumers
(Abdelsalam, 2016) but there has been no study whether there is a significant influence
of integral emotions and incidental emotions on the impulse buying behavior and how it
affects impulse post-purchase behavior in online environment.
There are 4 types of Impulse Buying, namely (1) Pure Impulse Buying is an implicit
purchase that is carried out by consumers outside of their habits that are often done by
consumers. (2) Reminder Impulse Buying is an impulsive purchase made by consumers
because they suddenly remember certain things, for example, remembering that the stock
of rice is running low at home and impulsively buying rice in the market without a prior
plan. (3) Suggestion Impulse Buying, an impulse purchase that occurs after a consumer
sees a product, and immediately feels in need without prior knowledge and in-depth
evaluation of the product (4) Planned Impulse Buying is an impulse purchase that is
determined from the availability of special offers such as discounts, special prices
according to expectations. This happens when a consumer logs into a web to make a
specific purchase but buys something else because there is a special offer for the day. In
this study, the 3rd type of impulse purchase is used because the other type departs from
the consumer's cognition process while this type 3 purchase is carried out without a plan,
prior knowledge, and needs, and is carried out immediately after the consumer sees the
product.
Research Methods
This study involved 100 respondents with 60% of respondents being women and
the rest being men. All respondents admitted to having made impulse purchases online in
Surabaya. Respondents were selected specifically with an age between 20 years and -35
years old and have worked. The data collected through questionnaires are analyzed with
Structural Equation Modelling to test the model and test the research hypothesis.
The focus of the study is to analyze the causal relationship between Emotion and
Impulsive Buying Behavior and how it affects Impulse Post-Purchase Behavior. There
Erna Ferrinadewi
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3092
are 4 variables in this study, namely the variables of Incidental Emotions, Integral
Emotions, Impulsive Purchase Behavior, and Post-Impulsive Purchase Behavior.
Results and Discussion
A total of 100 respondents were involved in this study with a total of 40 male
respondents and the rest were women. The age of respondents is from 21 years old to 50
years old who are actively making online purchases. Platforms that are often used are
Shopee and Tokopedia.
Table 1
Respondent Description
Percentage
Percentage
Gender
Online shopping
Legal Law
40%
<4x per month
40%
Woman
60%
5 10x per month
52%
Age
>10x per month
8%
21 - 30
37%
Platform Online
31 40
35%
Shopee
44%
41 50
27%
Tokopedia
20%
Education
Loop
14%
Bachelor
46%
BliBli
10%
Below
Undergraduate
54%
Bukalapak
12%
In purchasing behavior for the most frequently purchased products is the fashion
product category in a planned manner at 42% and impulsively at 40.2%. Beauty care
products are the second most purchased product category with 30% of respondents and
28.5% of respondents purchasing without a plan. The interesting thing is that in the
category of food and beverage products, 6% of respondents bought it in a planned manner,
but 10% of respondents admitted that they had bought it impulsively.
Table 2
Description of Data Distribution by Product Category
Product Categories
Products
purchased
suddenly, without
a plan
Frequently purchased
products online
Fashion
40.2%
42%
Beauty care products
28.5%
30%
Electronics
2.6%
2%
Home Furnishings Products
5%
7%
Health Products
5.7%
10%
Books and stationery
7.4%
3%
Food and Beverage
10.6%
6%
Model Measurements
The research model was tested using PLS-SEM with the consideration that PLS-
SEM is widely used in social research, especially in the field of marketing (Chan et al.,
2017). The second consideration is that for model prediction with a small sample size of
Integral Emotions and Incidental Emotions of Consumers in Impulse Buying Behavior
Online
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3093
less than 500 respondents, PLS-SEM is the right statistical tool to use. In addition, PLS-
SEM can also be used to make predictions.
Table 3
Construct Measurement
Indicator
Loading
Alpha
CR
BIRD
X1.1 Feeling after seeing product
photos
0.622
0.729
0.798
0.654
X1.2 Feelings after knowing the
availability of product
variations
0.493
X1.3 Testimonials after seeing
reviews from other buyers
-0.657
X2.1 Feeling of happiness
0.925
0.952
0.964
0.871
X2.2 Feeling of optimism
0.922
X2.3 Feelings of hopelessness
0.927
X2.4 Feelings of worry
0.958
Z1.1 Spontaneous purchase
without a plan
0.859
0.749
0.855
0.665
Z1.2 Fast purchase without delay
to pay
0.881
Z1.3 Surprise purchases without
prior planning
0.693
Y1.1 Positive feelings after
impulse purchases
0.859
0.725
0.773
0.632
Y1.2 Negative feelings after
impulsive purchases
0.724
In the construction test, the Cronbach Alpha and Composite reliability (CR) values
used to test the consistency of the internal model showed that it was at the recommended
level above 0.70. The factor loading value of all constructs shows a value above 0.70
except for the integral emotions construct indicator X1.2 with a value of 0.493. This
indicator is not removed from the model because this action does not correct the average
value of extracted variance, only if there is an improvement in the average value of
extracted variance then this item can be removed from the model.
Erna Ferrinadewi
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3094
Figure 1
Hasil Part Least Square Model
All hypotheses are analyzed using path coefficients, T Statistic, P-Value, and
standard deviation to determine the acceptance or rejection of the hypothesis. Based on
the structural model, all hypotheses are proven except for hypothesis 1 with a Probability
value above 0.05. While hypotheses 2 and 3 are accepted with a Probability value below
0.05. shown in Table 4 below.
Table 4
Hasil PLS-SEM
Direct Effect
Path
Coefficient
s
T-
Statistic
s
Standar
d
Deviatio
n
P
Value
Result
H1 Integral Emotions
Impulsive Buying Behavior
-0.090
0.513
0.175
0.608
Unprove
n
H2 Incidental Emotions
Impulsive Buying
Behavior
0.204
2.036
0.100
0.042
Evident
H3 Impulsive Buying
Behavior Post Impulse
Buying Behavior
0.450
7.287
0.057
0.000
Evident
Integral Emotions significantly influence impulsive buying behavior.
Integral emotions in this study hurt implicit purchasing behavior, not significant.
This emotion is felt by consumers as a response to the stimulus provided by the seller. In
this study, the availability of products, the availability of product variations, and the
existence of reviews from other consumers are the stimuli that shape this emotion. This
finding is different from previous research where online platforms, things such as product
placement, display design, promotions, music, and written text online media have a
positive impact on emotions in impulse purchases (Chan et al., 2017).
Integral Emotions and Incidental Emotions of Consumers in Impulse Buying Behavior
Online
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3095
The feelings consumers feel after seeing a product photo do not trigger the desire
to buy quickly without an in-depth evaluation. This is because many unplanned purchases
tend to occur due to the emotional condition of consumers formed from attractive product
offers so buyers often ignore the benefits of the product in alternative evaluations.
Meanwhile, in online purchases, the main limitation is the opportunity for consumers to
receive and process stimuli physically, so consumers tend to decide not to buy quickly.
Although it is not significant in the study, the tendency not to make impulse purchases
can occur due to concerns about feeling disappointed after the purchase (Zhao, Li, Wang,
Zhou, & Luo, 2022).
The availability of product variety has a negative relationship with impulse buying
behavior online. When online businesses use the factor of limited product variety
availability, even though the scarcity or limited variety of products is a strategy that is
often used to attract buyers by creating certain emotions, it turns out that in the context of
online impulse buying behavior, this has a negative relationship, this situation encourages
buyers to switch to searching on other shopping platforms (Thuong, 2020). Conversely,
too much variety available will reduce impulse buying impulse. Although in this study,
the relationship between product variation and impulse buying behavior was not
significant due to the breadth of products studied, it can be concluded that this negative
relationship is caused by (1) too many choices, causing negative feelings in the form of
worries about the potential for unsatisfactory purchases (Schwarz & Clore, 1983;
Inyengar, 2001) and (2) demand more cognitive processes. Feelings of fear and demands
for more cognitive processes make consumers less motivated to make impulse purchases.
Reviews of other buyers in this study hurt impulse buying behavior but are not
significant because in this study the products studied are not specific. Although it is still
not significant, it can be explained that this negative relationship can occur when buyer
reviews contain a high emotional load, which can increase consumer curiosity for certain
types of products. Consumers naturally have a yearly appetite and because of this,
emotionally charged buyer reviews can attract attention and spark curiosity. Fear, worry,
anger, and anxiety that are read in online buyer reviews are read more clearly.
Incidental Emotions significantly influence impulsive buying behavior.
Incidental Emotions can be formed from positive emotions and negative emotions
and it was found in this study that there was a significant influence of the Incidental
Emotions variable on impulse buying behavior of 0.204. The emotions that consumers
feel before a purchase provide a strong motivational boost to make a purchase
spontaneously. Incidental emotions are not formed as a consumer response to a
product/brand marketing program, but these emotions already exist and originate from
situations that have nothing to do with the product. This kind of behavior can improve the
previous negative emotional state. On the other hand, when the emotional condition is
positive, the impulsive buying behavior that is carried out tends to make consumers ignore
the negative consequences of their actions. Positive feelings, negativity, feelings of guilt,
and buying due to mood are emotional reactions that trigger impulse purchases.
Erna Ferrinadewi
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3096
Consumers often feel negative emotions such as anxiety. The anxiety felt by
consumers varies in causes. For example, because they are in the process of making
investment decisions, perceptions of the safety and halal of food, and social problems. In
the context of online purchases, the negative emotions of anxiety in this study have the
largest loading factor in the incidental emotions construct so it can be said that the anxiety
that consumers are experiencing encourages consumers to make purchases spontaneously
when they successfully access the internet compared to positive emotions such as
happiness, pride, and feeling great. In negative emotional situations such as sadness,
consumers can become very compelled to overcome or get out of their negative feelings
as soon as possible without even thinking deeply the consumer is willing to pay a higher
price, and the hope of obtaining post-purchase happiness becomes a strong motivation.
The feeling of joy that consumers feel before an impulsive purchase can be
expressed in the form of enthusiastic behavior or a calmer form of behavior, but these two
things determine the specifics of the purchase, even in detail consumers can determine
the brand they buy, the product they choose, or even the music they want to listen to
(Mogilner, 2012). In general, happy individuals are generally less likely to mind buying
at a higher price compared to consumers who previously had neutral emotions in an online
transaction environment. It can be explained that in a strong positive emotional state,
individuals will have difficulties in cognition and controlling their behaviour, resulting in
impulsive behaviour.
This finding is to the opinion (Kabamba & Smith, 2022) that consumers can make
impulse purchases because they are driven by their emotional state before the purchase in
order to improve their mood and negative emotions felt previously. Positive emotions
also encourage consumers to make impulse purchases as a gratuity to themselves, even
consumers are willing to pay more for products that are not relevant to their needs.
Impulsive buying behaviour affects post-purchase emotions.
It was found significant in this study that the influence of impulsive buying
behaviour on the emotions felt by consumers after purchase. Impulsive post-purchase
feelings can occur as either positive emotions or negative emotions. This is the opinion
that there are 2 emotions, one of which can be felt by consumers after impulse purchases,
namely the emotion of feeling comfortable and the emotion of feeling guilty (Togawa,
Ishii, Onzo, & Roy, 2020).
These negative feelings can stem from purchase problems that are beyond financial
ability or from insults/ridicule from others. Negative feelings that arise after impulsive
behavior are caused by consumers feeling that they have failed to control themselves (Li,
2015), and regret due to the purchase of products that are not needed. Positive feelings
such as comfort, happiness, and satisfaction felt after an impulsive purchase are caused
not only because this purchase decision was made emotionally and the low self-control
of consumers in their decisions (Gardner, 1998) but also because of the sensation of
excitement and relaxation felt during shopping.
Integral Emotions and Incidental Emotions of Consumers in Impulse Buying Behavior
Online
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3097
Conclusion
This study proves the positive and significant influence of integral emotion on
impulsive buying behaviour. A positive and significant influence was also found between
impulse buying behavior on post-impulse purchase emotions in an online environment.
A negative influence was found on the involuntary emotion on impulse buying behavior,
this kind of relationship can occur because, in the online environment, consumers become
very limited in evaluating the marketing stimuli provided by marketers in online media.
These findings require further study with a larger sample size, more specific product
categories, and separation of behaviors between men and women given that differences
in emotional management between men and women have different tendencies.
Erna Ferrinadewi
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3098
Bibliography
Achar, Chethana, So, Jane, Agrawal, Nidhi, & Duhachek, Adam. (2016). What we feel
and why we buy: the influence of emotions on consumer decision-making. Current
Opinion in Psychology, 10, 166170. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copsyc.2016.01.009
Chan, Tommy K. H., Cheung, Christy M. K., & Lee, Zach W. Y. (2017). The state of
online impulse-buying research: A literature analysis. Information & Management,
54(2), 204217.
Haq, Mirza A., & Abbasi, Salman. (2016). Indirect impact of hedonic consumption and
emotions on impulse purchase behaviour: A double mediation model. Journal of
Management Sciences, 3(2), 108122.
Kabamba, Chloé C., & Smith, Calvin. (2022). The Role of Consumers’ Emotions in
Online Impulse Buying of Fashion Apparel. International Journal of Business and
Social Science Research, 3(9), 18. https://doi.org/10.47742/ijbssr.v3n9p1
Kamis, Fatin Farhana, & Zulkiffli, Wan Farha Wan. (2020). Online trust development in
online shopping. International Research Conference on Social Sciences (3rd IRCSS
2020), 157.
Moreira, António C., Fortes, Nuno, & Santiago, Ramiro. (2017). Influence of sensory
stimuli on brand experience, brand equity, and purchase intention. Journal of
Business Economics and Management, 18(1), 6883.
Patiro, Shine Pintor Siolemba, Budiyanti, Hety, & Hendarto, Kresno Agus Hendriana.
(2022). Panic-buying behavior during the Covid-19 Pandemic in Indonesia: A
social cognitive theoretical model. Gadjah Mada International Journal of Business,
24(1), 2555.
Sharma, Anshuman, Dwivedi, Rohita, Mariani, Marcello M., & Islam, Tahir. (2022).
Investigating the effect of advertising irritation on digital advertising effectiveness:
A moderated mediation model. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 180,
121731.
Thuong, Nguyen Uyen. (2020). Factors affecting online impulse buying of consumers in
Hue City. Hue University Journal of Science: Economics and Development,
129(5A), 2946.
Togawa, Taku, Ishii, Hiroaki, Onzo, Naoto, & Roy, Rajat. (2020). Effects of consumers’
construal levels on post-impulse purchase emotions. Marketing Intelligence &
Planning, 38(3), 269282.
Yu, Yongjuan. (2022). Effects of negative emotions and cognitive characteristics on
impulse buying during COVID-19. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, 848256.
Integral Emotions and Incidental Emotions of Consumers in Impulse Buying Behavior
Online
Jurnal Indonesia Sosial Teknologi, Vol. 5, No. 7, July 2024 3099
Zhao, Yang, Li, Yixuan, Wang, Ning, Zhou, Ruoxin, & Luo, Xin. (2022). A meta-
analysis of online impulsive buying and the moderating effect of economic
development level. Information Systems Frontiers, 24(5), 16671688.